Summary: Video surveillance can be a positive influence in the protection of people, property, and business results if it is properly implemented. This guide sets out the dos and don’ts of video surveillance, the workplace video surveillance laws that must be complied with, the Workplace Video Surveillance Laws to consider, and how to develop a workplace video surveillance policy that is clear and protects the privacy of employees.
Important: It is highly recommended that any business considering video surveillance seek advice from qualified legal professionals to ensure compliance with all laws and regulations. While this guide is intended for general information purposes only, it is not intended to be considered legal advice.
Are your security cameras working for you or against your workplace in ways that you never thought possible? Video surveillance has become an accepted norm in most offices, warehouses, and other forms of commercial settings, yet most organizations are installing security cameras without any rules and guidelines in place.
Without a proper understanding of the concept of surveillance, organizations are at risk of facing privacy issues, legal issues, and a loss of trust among employees. Surveillance, when properly managed, can improve workplace safety, accountability, and monitoring. The biggest difference between poorly managed surveillance and properly managed surveillance is the presence of a video surveillance policy in the workplace.
What Is Workplace Video Surveillance and Why Is It Used?
Workplace video surveillance means the use of cameras for observation, recording, or monitoring of activities carried out on the business premises. It is used by organizations to prevent and investigate theft and to enhance safety. In addition, video surveillance is used in various industries to aid audits and insurance claims.
Research conducted by various industry reports indicates that a large percentage of businesses in the United States are employing video surveillance and are experiencing a reduction in theft and other unauthorized activities. To exemplify this, it has been identified that approximately 70% of retailers in the United States are employing video surveillance for the prevention of theft, and about 30% of these businesses are experiencing a reduction in theft.
The aim is not constant observation. The aim is accountability and protection.
What Workplace Video Surveillance Laws Should Employers Consider?
Here are the key Workplace Video Surveillance Laws to consider when deploying and managing surveillance systems in U.S. workplaces.
United States Considerations
In the United States, the rules and regulations regarding workplace surveillance vary from state to state, but some basic principles are followed everywhere. For example, employers are required to inform employees about the surveillance and make sure that it is for a valid business purpose, such as security and loss prevention. Video recording in an area where employees have a reasonable expectation of privacy, as well as audio recording, is illegal in most states without consent.
Other states, like California, have more stringent privacy laws that require transparency and the proper use of the data obtained from the surveillance system. There are also issues of retention, access, and disclosure that employers need to be aware of.
International and GDPR-Influenced Rules
In international business operations, there is a need to have a legal basis for the implementation of CCTV, minimum data collection, minimum data retention, and communication to employees. There is an expectation to demonstrate the need for the implementation of CCTV systems within the business.
Due to the differing and often changing nature of surveillance laws, businesses are advised to seek advice from legal counsel before implementing any workplace surveillance system.
Why Is a Video Surveillance in the Workplace Policy Essential?
A written video surveillance in the workplace policy turns intent into structure. The application of video surveillance in the workplace has a purpose if it is carried out in an organized way, following certain guidelines. If guidelines are not followed, video surveillance can be considered unfair or intrusive, even if it is applied for a good reason. Video surveillance policy in the workplace is an organized manner of implementing video surveillance to help in understanding the role of video surveillance in safety, security, and productivity.
Key Reasons a Video Surveillance Policy Is Essential
- It specifies the goal of the surveillance, e.g., safety, loss prevention, or compliance, and also prevents its misuse.
- It indicates where cameras are allowed and where monitoring is not allowed.
- It also determines who has access to recorded videos and under what circumstances.
- It defines the practices for retaining and storing data to meet legal and privacy needs.
- It also reduces disputes between employees by clearly stating expectations from the beginning.
- It offers proof of compliance, which is documented in audits, investigations, or legal reviews.
An established policy ensures a controlled and transparent practice of surveillance rather than an uncontrolled risk.
Where Should Cameras Be Installed and Where Are They Prohibited?
Camera placement matters more than camera count.
Appropriate Areas for Surveillance
Cameras are often allowed in entrance and exit doors, parking lots, loading docks, production floors, and public customer areas. These are often for safety and asset protection.
Areas Where Cameras Should Never Be Used
Restrooms, locker rooms, private offices, and break rooms are generally off-limits. Monitoring these areas almost always breaches the norms of privacy and, in many areas, the law.
In most cases, if the space implies a level of personal privacy, then surveillance does not belong.
What Are the Do’s of Workplace Video Surveillance?
Every effective surveillance program follows a few clear principles.
Do Provide a Clear Notice
Employees should be aware of the location of cameras and the purpose of the cameras. Signage can help, and written policies can help even better.
Do Define a Specific Purpose
The surveillance must be for safety, security, or compliance. The surveillance cannot be vague or open-ended.
Do Limit Access to Footage
Access to recorded footage should be limited to authorized personnel only. This will help prevent misuse of the footage and also ensure that employee privacy is protected.
Do Set Retention Limits
Footage should only be stored for a necessary period. For most organizations, that is between 14 and 45 days unless an incident requires a longer retention.
What Are the Don’ts Employers Must Avoid?
Common mistakes in workplace surveillance programs are of the same nature. It is equally important to avoid mistakes as it is to use the appropriate technology.
Don’t Use Cameras for Constant Employee Monitoring
The aim of surveillance should be to enhance security and safety, not to monitor the minute-by-minute activities of employees. Too much surveillance can result in mistrust and may result in legal and HR issues.
Don’t Collect More Data Than Necessary
Do not record too much or too detailed footage when there is no valid reason for it. Recording desks, workstations, or computer screens is unnecessary and may lead to privacy breaches. Record only what is required to meet a well-articulated need.
Don’t Ignore Employee Concerns or Complaints
Employee concerns and complaints should be addressed and clarified, not punished. A clear procedure for handling concerns shows that the company is transparent and committed to building trust.
Don’t Install Cameras Without Clear Notice or Documentation
Cameras that are hidden or not properly documented can be a source of potential non-compliance. Employees should be clearly notified about the location of cameras and the reason for the surveillance.
How Should Employers Handle Consent and Transparency?
Consent does not necessarily entail filling out a form, but it must be transparent. Employees must not be left wondering if, where, and why they are being surveilled.
It must be easy for the new employee to understand the practices of surveillance by explaining them during the hiring process. It must also not be difficult for the new employee to understand where the cameras are located, what their purpose is, and how to access them. In the event of any change, such as the installation of new cameras or an extension of their use, it must be given in advance.
In some instances, a written acknowledgment or consent may be necessary. In all instances, surprise surveillance is present, which can be dangerous. Notice, communication, and written policies are essential in preventing conflicts and ensuring proper usage of monitoring in the workplace.
How Can Video Surveillance Respect Employee Privacy?
Employee privacy is maintained through proper design and controlled usage. Cameras should be set to monitor areas rather than individuals. Wide views should be used instead of close tracking shots. Areas unrelated to the security purpose should be masked or excluded. Audio recording should be avoided unless it is clearly allowed.
Footage has to be treated as sensitive information with restricted access and a retention policy. If surveillance is used judiciously, employees may see surveillance as a protective measure rather than an invasion.
What Role Does Data Security Play in Surveillance Compliance?
Video footage is basically a type of data, and this implies that video surveillance is a security matter. The video footage captured during the surveillance process contains information, movement, and operations that are equally important.
Encryption, secure storage, role-based access control, and audit trails are also necessary to prevent misuse or unauthorized use. If video data is compromised, the consequences are serious. A secure surveillance system is not an option. It is as necessary as the written policy that controls its use.
Conclusion: Surveillance Works Best When It Is Accountable
Video surveillance in the workplace is neither positive nor negative in and of itself. Its effects are contingent on the motivations for its use, its design, and its parameters. When organizational policies are in sync with the law and proper management of the system is practiced, surveillance cameras are a positive force in workplace safety.
At Resolute Partners, we assist organizations in designing and deploying a compliant, transparent, and effective video surveillance system. Our approach is centered on a system that is compliant with regulatory requirements while also gaining the trust of employees. We therefore ensure that our surveillance systems meet regulatory requirements while also being effective.
All organizations should consult their legal counsel before implementing or updating workplace surveillance policies to ensure full compliance and reduce liability risks.
Ready to build a surveillance program that protects your people and your business?
Contact Resolute Partners today to design a compliant, enterprise-grade video surveillance solution that earns trust while reducing risk.
FAQs
Q1. Is Workplace Video Surveillance Legal Without Employee Consent?
In some regions, consent is not required, but notice is mandatory. The rules differ from region to region, and the employer must check them before sending them out.
Q2. Can an Employer Monitor an Employee’s Activity Through Cameras Around the Clock?
Continuous monitoring for productivity or employee behavior is not advisable and can also be illegal. The monitoring has to be for a valid security reason.
Q3. How Long Should Workplace Video Footage Be Stored?
Most companies store the video footage for a particular period, which is between 14 and 45 days, unless there is a valid reason.
Q4. Are Audio Recordings Allowed with Video Surveillance?
Audio recording is very limited and must be authorized. Audio recording is limited in most countries. Do not record audio unless authorized.
Q5. What Happens If a Company Violates Workplace Surveillance Laws?
Fines, lawsuits, and damage to reputation will be incurred, and these issues are alleviated by having a proper policy and system in place.
Michael S. Blanco is the Chief Executive Officer and Co-Founder of Resolute Partners, LLC, where he leads strategic initiatives across various divisions. After owning family entertainment centers in New England, he co-founded Resolute Partners in 1996, launching the first Internet cafés for the U.S. Navy and partnering with AT&T for global deployment. A pioneer in wireless communications, Michael has expanded the company’s focus to include Energy Management/IoT, Cybersecurity, and Managed Video Security. He holds a degree from the Rochester Institute of Technology.
Stay up to date.
Subscribe for latest news, protection tips, special offers, and more!
Live Video Monitoring
Our trained video security surveillance monitoring professionals can quickly spot suspicious activity captured by business security cameras. We review live video to determine if criminal behavior is suspected.
